American Legends

What a gem!!! This store is awesome! Friendly owners. We have to appreciate this store. Very few like it.Angel Andrews is lying. His review is not true or accurate. This is a wholesome family business, they even let my pet in.

Every time I go into this store I feel like a little kid again. Plenty of shops in my area but I go out of my way to get here because the service and the people are incredible. They always have the best prices and Donna and Mark are an absolute pleasure to deal with. It’s my sons favorite shop as well.

Very friendly and helpful! Prices are incredibly reasonable. With the pandemic, prices of some items have skyrocketed online. But they’ve kept their prices fair and cheaper than Amazon! Bought a load of card cases / protectors and card packs.

I have been coming here for years and Mark and his wife are the absolute best. Mark is fair with his prices and trades (he will actually EXPLAIN to you why certain cards are certain prices). BUT most importantly Mark actually LOVES the hobby and is always willing to engage in conversation with you. He has also given me great advice on becoming a collector (do it because you love it and not to make money) in addition to what to look out for and be weary of. I will continue to happily give him my business and am thrilled for all the success they have had. They deserve it.

Absolutely amazing. Was loads of fun getting to jump back into cards, 80s and 90s style 🔥🔥🔥

I just found out cards are a thing again. Donna took the time to share her wealth of knowledge about how I should go about valuing my collection. 💲🤔❓

The best part was reliving some of my sports memories from childhood.

I found their prices extremely reasonable, and Donna even steered me away from pricier options and helped me get the most value for my money.

I got some hobby boxes from the 90s and can't wait to open them. Even if you could find a slightly cheaper price online like some say, American Legends is by far your better option, for a few reasons.

1) You can't even put a price on their knowledge. It's invaluable, and well worth the small markup. The advice probably saved me dozens of hours sorting through what I have.

2) They have an awesome staff that's fun to talk to, about baseball cards, basketball cards or anything else sports.

3) They're right here in Westchester, NY helping to support our community. Plus, they're trustworthy. And local if you ever have a problem.

Definitely worth stopping by, relive some memories about cards and then go home, and rub it in your parents face that you weren't just throwing away your money as a kid😜👌